Commentary: Don't burden C.M. businesses with higher fees

August 02, 2013|By Colin McCarthy

The July 31 Daily Pilot article "Officials postpone business tax review," highlights a disturbing trend by a small but vocal minority in Costa Mesa — blame Nordstrom and South Coast Plaza for not paying their fair share of taxes.

For years, some in our community have used Nordstrom as a punching bag to argue that Costa Mesa's business license fee (tax) should be raised. Pundits love to highlight the fact that Nordstrom is no different than any other business in our city when it comes to paying its business license tax. This is simply their way of saying that we should raise our business tax.

Here are some interesting facts that don't get reported. Nordstrom is consistently one of Costa Mesa's top 25 sales-tax generators. More people travel from LA, San Diego, Europe, Asia, etc., to shop at South Coast Plaza, making it the highest sales-generating shopping center in the nation. Last fiscal year, South Coast Plaza contributed more than $15 million in sales tax revenue to our city general fund. In fact, the Plaza alone accounts for over a third of our city's general fund sales tax.


For some, Nordstrom and South Coast Plaza's contributions are not enough. They somehow believe that because large businesses like Nordstrom max out at $200 per year in business license taxes, they aren't paying their fair share.

This argument is absurd.

Nordstrom pays more than its fair share of taxes through sales tax, unemployment tax, workers compensation and a whole host of other taxes this state deems necessary to saddle businesses with. Now we want to soak them for more?

Costa Mesa is blessed to receive South Coast Plaza's sales taxes. We should be thanking large businesses like Nordstrom for being in our city and providing much-needed tax revenue. We certainly should not be looking for more ways to bleed them through a nickel and dime tax.

What do businesses like Nordstrom receive in exchange for paying this tax? Increased city services? Business outreach? Advertising? Something to help their bottom line?

The answer is very little — a certificate to hang on their wall. The business license fee is simply a tax-generating mechanism for the city that provides no tangible return benefit to local businesses.

I hope readers will ask themselves an important question about our major businesses. Where would Costa Mesa be without Nordstrom?

If we simply picked up South Coast Plaza and moved it one block north to Santa Ana, what would our city look like?

Daily Pilot Articles Daily Pilot Articles