Commentary: Common Core math program needs far more study

May 20, 2013|By Janet Geehr

Re. "Apodaca: Common Core may add up to math skills boost we need," (May 12): Patrice Apodaca's enthusiasm for the new Common Core math program, based on her belief that it will improve students' math skills, grabbed my attention.

As a former teacher and the parent of three Newport-Mesa students, education is paramount to me. Apodaca inspired me to investigate Common Core; I do not share her optimism.

Improving students' math skills is a laudable goal. However, the only mathematician on the Common Core Validation Committee, Stanford professor James Milgram, refused to sign off on the standards. He cited a plethora of "extremely serious failings" and concluded that the program is unlikely to achieve the desired results. This academic expert's input was ignored.


If, in fact, the Common Core Standards are a true improvement, why were they snuck into schools without a comment period, legislative discussion or vote?

I earned my teaching credential during the 1980s, when the educational trend was to abandon phonics, so I understand the long-term consequences of bad bureaucratic decisions. Parents were never afforded the opportunity to ask questions in advance of Common Core; it was presented as a fait accompli. Californians are now committed to spending more than $2 billion (Pioneer Institute estimate) to implement an unproven system.

Apodaca quotes Steve McLaughlin, Newport-Mesa's director of secondary curriculum and instruction: "I think absolutely our kids are going to learn math better. ... The research shows it."

What research? I could find nothing to support McLaughlin's claim. In fact a recurring theme of critics, including the expert advisors who refused to validate the standards, is that this system has not been tested.

McLaughlin cited a Common Core middle-school math lesson in which students try to guess the number of chickpeas it would take to fill a classroom. He expressed confidence that such an exercise would help develop an understanding of space and measurements and demonstrate the creative thinking that is lacking in traditional teaching methods.

It is also an example of the "mental math" at the center of Common Core math. Parents across the country whose kids are already being taught in this method are complaining fiercely. As a result of parent and teacher activism, 18 states are considering legislation to block its implementation.

Daily Pilot Articles Daily Pilot Articles