Advertisement

A Word, Please: Politicians are great grammar faux pas fodder

August 31, 2012|By June Casagrande

Say what you will about election season. But for some people, it's a boon.

Poised to profit from the nonstop bickering and blustering are network advertising sales reps, political pundits, earplug manufacturers, comedy writers and liquor stores.

Add professional language geeks to the lists. Since the days when Dan Quayle extended a welcome to "President Bush, Mrs. Bush and my fellow astronauts," elections have been a time when a candidate's every little word gets pounced on, scrutinized and criticized — much to the glee of nitpickers like me.

Advertisement

Not long ago, there was fun to be had with the Romney camp's misspelling of "America." Now the Obama slogan "Forward." is drawing criticism. Or at least it's drawing reports that it's drawing criticism. As with any news item, you can never be sure how much "reaction" took place before reporters started calling experts asking for their reaction.

Don't see what's wrong with the slogan? It's not those quotation marks. Those are mine, used to indicate that I'm quoting the slogan. Nor is the word misspelled. Though it's easy to confuse "forward," which is a direction, with "foreword," which comes at the beginning of a book, the Obama campaign team got it right.

The problem with the slogan: the period.

"Those who brandish red pens for a living are divided on whether Mr. Obama's campaign slogan passes muster," the Wall Street Journal reported earlier this month in an article about the period. Some experts, the newspaper reported, dubbed it grammatically incorrect because "Forward." is not a complete sentence. Others, like UC Berkeley linguistics professor George Lakoff, say it is correct because "Forward." is an imperative sentence.

Actually, they're all wrong.

Let's start with the idea that "Forward." is an imperative sentence.

In grammar, an imperative is a command. "Pass the sugar." It's distinguished from declarative sentences, which are statements. "Joe passes the sugar." And it's different from interrogative sentences, which are questions. "Did Joe pass the sugar?"

In the imperative form "Pass the sugar," Joe is nowhere to be found because imperatives leave the subject implied. That's not a problem because the subject is always the same. It's "you." When you say, "Pass the sugar," the subject of the action is always an implied "you."

Daily Pilot Articles Daily Pilot Articles
|
|
|