City Life: Hubbard could be re-hired

February 07, 2012|By Steve Smith

Bureaucracies are as predictable as sunrises.

So it should not surprise anyone that the Newport-Mesa Unified trustees chose one former superintendent, Robert Barbot, to replace another former superintendent, Jeffrey Hubbard, who was recently convicted of two felonies.

Barbot is now the interim superintendent — a placeholder, someone who will keep the chair warm until a third superintendent gets on this merry-go-round by July 1.


Barbot is the safe-but-expensive choice. As a pensioner who made $227,057 in retirement benefits last year, Barbot could earn about $100,000, plus expenses, from his interim superintendent job over the next five months.

Life for Barbot is good.

We may not have seen the last of Hubbard. He has said he will appeal the verdict, and because the sentiment of the school board is that he is guilty until proven otherwise, a reversal of his conviction could put pressure on the board to re-hire him.

After all, if he is eventually cleared, why should he lose his job? To avoid a lawsuit, the contract for the new superintendent should include a clause that the agreement may be voided at the discretion of the trustees, with an appropriate payout, should Hubbard win on appeal.

The contract is a matter that requires thoughtful judgment now, during the time when the board is searching for Hubbard's replacement. The trustees should not take the easy route and use the Hubbard contract as a template for the new superintendent.

The extra annual incentives that paid Hubbard while the compensation for others fell — or their contributions to medical or pension programs increased — should be eliminated. The new superintendent's compensation should be fixed and increases should be subject to a vote of the trustees.

Trustee votes regarding the new superintendent are important now, particularly that of Walt Davenport, who once said to the Daily Pilot: "I don't believe [Hubbard] will be found guilty," and "I think the whole thing is trumped up" ("Board leader stands by supt.," July 5).

In October, the Pilot reported that "Davenport said his steadfast support comes from his feelings about Hubbard's character and his belief that the charges won't stand up in court" ("School board stands by superintendent," Oct. 14).

After Hubbard's conviction last month, Davenport said: "I'm very surprised. I did not expect him to be found guilty" ("Search is on for Hubbard's replacement," Jan. 24).

Daily Pilot Articles Daily Pilot Articles