"We've known about TeWinkle Park for a long time," Odekirk told the council. "We believe it should be the jewel of this area."
The firm discussed renovating TeWinkle's grass fields and adding a restaurant that serves pizza and alcohol — the biggest generator of revenue for Big League Dreams sites.
Odekirk said his firm can add as many or as few amenities as the city likes.
Council members argued the park is under-utilized and costs hundreds of thousands to maintain annually, with little to show for the investment.
The firm would pay for the project at no cost to the city, Odekirk said.
Ultimately, council members split on the decision with a 3-1 vote. Council members Steve Mensinger, Jim Righeimer and Mayor Gary Monahan voted in favor. Councilwoman Wendy Leece dissented. Councilman Eric Bever was absent.
Big League Dreams' proposal met stiff resistance from Mesa del Mar homeowners, who pledged to oppose any plans that would increase lighting or noise from the park.
The council's choice came after hours of discussion, along with two other prospective firms telling the council it was moving too fast.
"From where I stand, the horse is a specific set of specifications that have been vetted that you've worked through with your residents," said Dave Johnson, president of Major League Softball Inc. "We're the carts. To select a cart tonight would be backwards."
Leece shared the same concerns.
When Mensinger and Righeimer questioned each firm about its business models, potential costs and revenues of operating TeWinkle Park, the business owners could only offer guesses.