That player was Freddy Perez and he wound up punishing Sage Hill.
The senior scored an incredible game-winning goal in the 97th minute. He celebrated in grand fashion, much to the dismay of the home crowd.
Sanchez never should have been on the field in overtime. Two yellow cards in a match is an automatic ejection.
But one of the referees admitted to booking the wrong No. 9 on the field the first time around, to the surprise to practically everyone at the match. When Sanchez got his second yellow late in regulation, the ref had it as his first.
The coaches and refs gathered before overtime to discuss the error made by the ref.
"He kind of left it up to us, and I did say, 'Hey, you know what? I think that the kid should play because it was a referee mistake and that's part of the game,'" Cid said.
The decision seemed to backfire on Cid.
Sage Hill (3-2-1 in league) is still looking up to the Wildcats (3-1-2) in the league standings. Whitney Coach Joe Rodriguez likes where his side is with four league matches left.
"It's putting us in a situation where we control our own destiny again," Rodriguez said. "It was a great battle."
It was battle that Rodriguez said he was willing to take part in without Sanchez in the lineup in overtime.
The Lightning faithful did not take too kind to the move to let Sanchez play. They yelled at the refs, and Cid looked back toward the stands a couple of times, trying to calm the fans down.
He could not do much to quiet them down when it was Sanchez ruining their night in the second 10-minute overtime period.
Sanchez dribbled from the left side and into the box before putting a move on a defender. He unleashed a shot in the box to beat goalkeeper Mason Weinstein.